Coachman’s Square Condos in New Canaan, CT

Opening Overview

The most useful thing to know about Coachman’s Square is that only 12 units exist in the entire complex, and verified MLS data shows just 8 sales over the past decade. That turnover rate tells you something important: owners here do not leave quickly. When a unit does come to market at Coachman’s Square, it tends to draw serious attention. Closed prices in the verified sales record range from $595,000 to $1,225,000, with a median of $645,500. The most recent sale, in April 2025, closed at $1,225,000 — a significant jump over the prior comps, and a signal that the market is repricing these units upward. At a town median of $2,080,000 for all property types, Coachman’s Square represents one of the lower entry points for New Canaan CT real estate, without giving up the three-bedroom, multi-bath layout that most buyers in this town require.

Coachman’s Square Condos for Sale

With only 12 units in the building, active inventory at Coachman’s Square is rarely deep. There is no standing inventory here the way there might be in a 60-unit complex. In a typical year, one or two units may come available. In some years, none do. If you are searching New Canaan CT condos and Coachman’s Square is a priority, the right move is to monitor it actively and position yourself to act when something surfaces — not to wait for a public listing and then start your due diligence. Contact The Engel Team for current availability and to be notified of any units before they hit the open market.

Recently Sold at Coachman’s Square

The MLS record for Coachman’s Square includes 8 confirmed sales. Here is the complete verified data:

Across the full record, unit sizes ran from 1,854 to 2,418 square feet. The median price per square foot across all 8 sales was approximately $318. The April 2025 sale of Unit 7 at $1,225,000 skews noticeably above every prior comp in the dataset. That single sale does not rewrite the median, but it does suggest that buyers underwriting a 2025 or 2026 purchase should not lean on 2017-era sales as their primary anchor. The spread here is wide enough that unit-specific condition, floor level, and any recent renovations will move the number significantly. Buyers should pull the full resale history for any unit they are considering — not just the most recent transaction.

About Coachman’s Square

Coachman’s Square is a small condominium complex of 12 townhouse-style units located at 259 New Norwalk Road in New Canaan, CT. The address places it on the New Norwalk Road corridor, which connects New Canaan’s town core to the surrounding residential landscape. The complex is not a high-rise and not a large-scale development. Twelve units is a deliberately small community, and that scale shapes everything about how the association functions: fewer owners, more direct communication, and a governance structure where every decision carries weight. The building style is townhouse, meaning units are vertically oriented rather than stacked flats, and most have their own entry configuration rather than a shared lobby. That detail matters to buyers who want something closer to a house than an apartment, with the tradeoff of a manageable HOA and no exterior maintenance responsibilities.

Homes and Layouts at Coachman’s Square

Based on the verified MLS record, units at Coachman’s Square are predominantly three-bedroom, three-bathroom configurations. One sale in the dataset recorded a four-bedroom, three-bathroom layout. Square footage across sold units ranged from 1,854 to 2,418 square feet — a meaningful spread within a 12-unit building, which suggests either varying unit sizes by design or that some units have been modified or combined over time. Buyers should verify exact square footage from the recorded deed or condominium declaration, not solely from listing data. The townhouse style typically means two or more levels, with living spaces on the entry level and bedrooms above. Outdoor space and parking arrangements for individual units should be confirmed directly through the association documents, as these details vary by unit in small complexes like this one.

What Buyers Need to Know

HOA fees in the verified record range from $396 to $560 per month, with the most commonly cited figure at $477/month. The April 2025 sale showed a fee of $556/month for Unit 7. Fee variations across units in a 12-unit building are normal, but buyers should request the current fee schedule and the most recent budget from the association before making an offer. Twelve-unit associations are small enough that a single large capital expenditure, a roof replacement, a parking structure repair, or an exterior project, can result in a special assessment that no individual owner can avoid by majority vote. Ask for the reserve study. If one does not exist or has not been updated recently, treat that as a material due diligence item.

Property taxes on the sold units ranged from $6,051 to $8,827 annually, with the higher end reflecting the most recent and highest-priced transaction. Tax assessment lag is real in Connecticut, so a unit purchased at the 2025 price point may carry a reassessed tax figure higher than what shows in the current record. Confirm the current assessed value with the New Canaan assessor’s office before closing. Buyers should also request the association’s master insurance policy to understand what is covered structurally versus what falls to individual unit owners. Rental policies and owner-occupancy ratios are not available in the verified data and must be confirmed directly with the association or its management company before making any assumptions about financing eligibility.

If you are financing the purchase with a conventional mortgage, lenders will require association documentation including the budget, reserve levels, delinquency rates, and owner-occupancy percentage. In a 12-unit building, those numbers can disqualify a loan quickly if one or two units are delinquent or investor-owned. Have your lender run a preliminary condo eligibility check early in the process. Buyers browsing New Canaan homes for sale more broadly will find that this type of pre-screen is standard due diligence for any small association in the area.

Buying or Selling at Coachman’s Square

A 12-unit building with 8 sales over a decade does not give you a thick comparable set. The April 2025 sale at $1,225,000 is the only data point with direct market relevance to a 2025 or 2026 transaction, and even that one sale needs context: unit condition, renovation scope, negotiation dynamics. Pricing a unit here accurately requires judgment, not just a spreadsheet. That is true whether you are buying or selling.

The Engel Team works the New Canaan condo market actively and can tell you what a specific unit at Coachman’s Square is actually worth in today’s market, not what it sold for in 2017. For sellers, the gap between the 2017-era comps and the 2025 sale price is significant — but only a unit-level analysis will tell you where your specific unit falls in that range. For buyers, understanding that spread is the difference between overpaying and making a well-positioned offer.

Contact The Engel Team for a current valuation, off-market monitoring, or a full condo due diligence walkthrough before you make any move at Coachman’s Square.

Videos